Love surprises? Our Mystery Cookie Box is the perfect way to treat yourself (or someone special) with a sweet surprise. Each box is packed with a rotating assortment of our fresh-baked cookies—sometimes classics, sometimes seasonal specialties—for a total value of up to $20 and never less than $10. It’s the best way to discover new favorites, enjoy variety, and get a little extra bakery magic in every box.
✨ What’s inside? That’s the fun part—you won’t know until you open the box!